Kill? by feili

[raw]
made by feili for LD25 (COMPO)
hello Ludum Dare, first time here, I'm going for a VERY small game... Since this is my second speedrun game (the first one was for the 7DFPS and was named Corpse Garden, and I learned a lot.) My concept is almost on the title... You are a villain... should you kill the victim?

I've rushed it fast! It's filthy, from graphics to code, but it's kind of finished in time. I'm using unity indie, by the way.

Oh, and there's an evil goat.

Ratings

Coolness 77% 2
Overall 2.44 641
Audio 2.87 225
Fun 1.69 753
Graphics 4.39 14
Humor 1.30 707
Innovation 2.23 656
Mood 3.61 50
Theme 3.78 114

Feedback

fishbrain
16. Dec 2012 路 17:41 UTC
...looks nice!
MrAmazingSocks
16. Dec 2012 路 19:13 UTC
cool
celsyum
16. Dec 2012 路 23:47 UTC
i got error : Bad file length :(
馃帳 feili
16. Dec 2012 路 23:59 UTC
Yep, I was uploading right then, unlucky you, but it should be okay by now! =)
rasmusrn
17. Dec 2012 路 10:32 UTC
Very moody. Well done.

Can I please have a cross hair? :)
kroltan
17. Dec 2012 路 10:37 UTC
Graphically, it's cool, but has a very limited interactivity.
Prelucid
17. Dec 2012 路 11:04 UTC
Reminds me of that experiment where people are fine hurting/torturing people as long as there's an authority sanctioning it or giving the orders. :)
ahmedcab
17. Dec 2012 路 13:06 UTC
nice graphics but very limited interactivity.
Corn茅 Dorrestijn
17. Dec 2012 路 14:34 UTC
Nice graphics and sound, sadly not much gameplay.
ignlg
17. Dec 2012 路 16:17 UTC
Interesting concept. That's all right now.
Xavier
17. Dec 2012 路 20:43 UTC
Really hard concept. Great atmosphere.
Winterblood
18. Dec 2012 路 00:45 UTC
Top-notch modelling and texturing, but movement sluggish and can clip through walls. Like the simplicity of the concept, but without any choice it feels forced, like the climax of The Darkness game. Thought-provoking though.
ilo
18. Dec 2012 路 01:29 UTC
Very dark, and great job on the modelling. Shame there isn't more to it though.
wzl
18. Dec 2012 路 10:26 UTC
Very grim and visually nice! Not much gameplay unfortunately.

I wrote a mini review: http://ldmr.wzl.vg/#feili

If you want me to link somewhere (twitter/else) let me know :)
Christina Antoinette Neofotistou
18. Dec 2012 路 21:26 UTC
You know the drill: not enough gameplay. It could be made into an artistic statement though, because the superb graphics and mood are very very compelling. It needs some more psychological elements. You could play with the prisoner pleading for his life, or that devil goat, why couldn't s/he be pressuring you to do it?

Cool idea though! Full marks for theme and mood
Christina Antoinette Neofotistou
18. Dec 2012 路 21:26 UTC
and graphics
mikemacdee
19. Dec 2012 路 07:20 UTC
there's no substance here at all. i feel like most of the dev time was spent making the models.
DustyStylus
19. Dec 2012 路 16:09 UTC
Good atmosphere, but I kinda expected a succession of different... erm... 'clients'? Ended a bit abruptly!

Does wanting more make me the villain? :)
pfirsich
19. Dec 2012 路 20:08 UTC
Nice graphics.
Codexus
20. Dec 2012 路 21:52 UTC
nice graphics but a bit short :)
馃帳 feili
20. Dec 2012 路 23:30 UTC
thanks for the comments about the graphics and mood, you guys are right about the rest, I just did not have enough time (birthdays...) to make a real game~ and I was already too tired to push my body further... so that was around 24 hours during which the dev time was spent on the models... at least I did that okay! =)
I really like the idea of a GoatMan pressuring you to kill him! I could also add some torture interactions... and maybe classic horror stuff like visions ghosts or else... I'll see about that later, thanks for the review and comments by the way! =)
DaviDeMo
20. Dec 2012 路 23:56 UTC
Mhm... interestin! lol
Husky
21. Dec 2012 路 02:07 UTC
Short but I do like the ambient.
Good work!
Pierrec
21. Dec 2012 路 10:25 UTC
WOAH! GRAPHICS!
rinaka
21. Dec 2012 路 17:18 UTC
Very good modeling. Very moody too! While playing I kept thinking about where this could go without the 48h time limit... maybe more objects to interact, so that the player can find out how things got to this point. And maybe an option for the villain to shoot himself?
Per
22. Dec 2012 路 15:11 UTC
Cool and scary!
Nice graphics and sound but a little short :)
SamoojaMies
23. Dec 2012 路 11:22 UTC
Has great mood, graphics and nailed the theme. Just too short. Good job anyways!
Niavlys
23. Dec 2012 路 12:37 UTC
Beautiful graphics and animations, and great mood. I gave your game bad ratings in Fun and Humor, but I guess you don't expect too much in these categories ;)
pereubu
23. Dec 2012 路 14:14 UTC
good idea for a "that small" game, replayed it several times to see if there's no other endings x)
csanyk
23. Dec 2012 路 23:17 UTC
Not much gameplay here, but from a ambiance and mood standpoint, this kicks butt. As a staging of an ethical dilemma, it's interesting. I only wonder what happens if you do not shoot. I waited around for a short time, but nothing happened, which was boring. Is there an alternate ending for a no-shoot player?
Bullseye8841
24. Dec 2012 路 00:41 UTC
Hmm. I would have like to have seen more done with the idea. Great work on the visuals. Thumbs up!
Mesene
26. Dec 2012 路 22:25 UTC
Nice assets, if man were begging for his life or some random inner thoughs mood will increase a lot :)
brantkings
27. Dec 2012 路 22:31 UTC
The graphics and mood are nice. But it left me wanting something more for sure.
michax
02. Jan 2013 路 09:00 UTC
A little to short :) Nice mood though.