The Shepherd by TheTopHatNoob

[raw]
made by TheTopHatNoob for LD 40 (COMPO)

Lead your sheep through the valley as wolves try to kill them.

Built in 48 hours solo for the compo event.

Ratings

Overall 476th 3.114⭐ 24🧑‍⚖️
Fun 371th 3.205⭐ 24🧑‍⚖️
Innovation 399th 3⭐ 24🧑‍⚖️
Theme 227th 3.659⭐ 24🧑‍⚖️
Graphics 526th 2.795⭐ 24🧑‍⚖️
Audio 305th 3.024⭐ 23🧑‍⚖️
Humor 420th 2.395⭐ 21🧑‍⚖️
Mood 445th 2.875⭐ 22🧑‍⚖️
Given 21🗳️ 26🗨️

Feedback

Asellio
04. Dec 2017 · 19:47 UTC
Pretty fun game. Tho because of how big the map is wouldve been nice if you added an arrow pointing towards the nearest sheep.
Move127
04. Dec 2017 · 19:59 UTC
## Praise

It's not the first herding mechanic I've seen in this jam, but I like the added requirement that you protect the sheep from wolves.

## Suggestions

Either make the map smaller or add more things in it. A pointer towards the nearest sheep would be nice as well.
🎤 TheTopHatNoob
04. Dec 2017 · 20:09 UTC
@move127 I definitely agree that I may have made the map to big. Originally I was going to have hundreds of sheep but for performance and gameplay reasons I dropped that. You can actually get up to 150 sheep so I kept the map big but thinking back on it the pacing does not justify the map size. Like the previous commenter said I should have added an arrow or something. I thought the far-out view would solve that problem but I realize now that l should have added an easier way to find sheep without resulting in opening your map every few seconds.
Ham and Swiss
04. Dec 2017 · 20:13 UTC
Edit: lol wrong game.
Move127
04. Dec 2017 · 20:15 UTC
@thetophatnoob

One possible solution for a post-compo release would be to have the map increase in size as you gain more sheep. This would give the game a nice feeling of progression.
6smith
04. Dec 2017 · 20:57 UTC
neat concept! i wish the wolf-hit-with-stick sound was slightly less cacophonous, though. definitely fits the theme.
🎤 TheTopHatNoob
04. Dec 2017 · 21:11 UTC
@move127 that would probably help fix what in my opinion is the greatest flow of the game right now, pacing. I was also thinking about changing the amount of sheep you get each day and such. But overall I think changing the map/map size would help accomplish the same thing.
papacheech
05. Dec 2017 · 00:00 UTC
I like the art style of this actually. I love herding games :) Good work!
Dave Siegel
05. Dec 2017 · 02:14 UTC
I dug the music a lot, but wasn't too hot on the other sound design. I'd rework the sound that plays when you hit a wolf. Your sheep work pretty well, and I enjoyed balancing the herding with fending off wolves. There is good tension between those two things.
jandourek
05. Dec 2017 · 07:05 UTC
I like this game, especially the music.
gwolf86
05. Dec 2017 · 10:12 UTC
Great work on this entry. The herding mechanic worked well but the map was a bit too large and empty, so it was difficult to find the sheep before the wolves came. I like the fact that you included an instructions screen and the background music was really nice.
elemel
05. Dec 2017 · 14:05 UTC
I liked it! Hard to keep track of the sheep, though. Didn't make it through day three. Those poor sheep.

Suggestion 0: Lower the volume of the sound effects.

Suggestion 1: Implement flocking simulation so that the sheep stay together most of the time, and move a bit smoother.

Suggestion 2: Sheep dogs!

Suggestion 3: Sheep can fall into pits or get stuck in bushes. Fish them out with your staff.
🎤 TheTopHatNoob
05. Dec 2017 · 15:33 UTC
@elemel I agree on all of those things. I was working on implementing suggestion 1 and 3 but only managed to get near but not finished with 1. Sheepdogs is a new idea though and I like it.
SlavicGames
05. Dec 2017 · 23:02 UTC
Well, we had similar idea :) Your concept is more natural, I like it.
kkneville
06. Dec 2017 · 03:22 UTC
I love this, it's do idyllic. What a great application of the theme.
Number6406
06. Dec 2017 · 18:14 UTC
I like the mood of this game, when wolfs spawn. First I didn't notice the timer so I was like "hey, it's pretty easy", and then wolfs started to kill all my sheep :sob:
I had few difficulties to hit the wolfs, but that's not a big problem.
Querk
26. Dec 2017 · 23:40 UTC
It is gives a lot of fun . I love idea :D Good job :D