I was rather picky this time. My criteria seemed to boil down to whether after rating fifty games it would still be fun and interesting to see everybody's interpretation.

Some of my favorites were: * If the state of florida had a baby * Inconvenient Superpower * Reverse Character Arc * Too Many Ducks * One Overpowered Ability * 1st World Problems * An Ant, a Pig, and a Dragon * Social Samurai * A new sport * Words Have Power

I down-voted every theme that seemed to advocate basic functions, like "The camera follows the player" or "Something changes", which are part of almost every game.

As far as voting on 3000+ themes is concerned...

I think rather than having every person vote on every theme, a playoff bracket might work better. X participants are grouped together and assigned X percentage of random themes to vote on, and then groups are reassigned and the winning themes go head to head, etc, etc...