Introducing the “Feedback Friends” mini-site!

Previously, in Ludum Dare…

In case you missed it, LD36 will be a little bit unusual, in that it won’t feature ratings.

To bring everyone up to date, the reason behind that is that PoV, when announcing his break from running the August LD, has also raised concerns over the ratings system. He recommended not to use it for this event, and following a poll made by Sorceress, we voted in majority to follow his advice.

Now, some of us really wanted to still find a cool incentive for players to play each other’s games. Ludum Dare may be enjoyed for the competition, but getting loads of playtesting and sharing feedback with each other is also a great part of what makes the event special.

So here comes our little experiment:

Click the logo to access the mini-site. Not me, the logo… Ok ok you can click me

 

The Feedback Friends mini-site

Here’s how it works:

Right after LD36 ends, you’ll be able to use this little thing to browse games and find those who need feedback the most. The more games you comment on, the higher you’ll be featured! The goal, of course, is to make sure everyone gets some comments on their games, and reward the more active commenters with more feedback.

If you’re curious, you can already browse the games from Ludum Dare 35 to get an idea of how it works.

Open beta: MiniLD #69

Starting today, the mini-site will be open for the current MiniLD in order to test things out, gather opinions and make some tweaks.

Please share your suggestions & bug reports in the comments. And if you’re curious, feel free to check the Github repository!

 

[Update] The Ludum Dare world map

Additional announcement: Will Edwards is looking for contributors (artists/programmers) to upgrade a project he made for LD30.

It featured a nice map of the world, where people could place their entries and find their neighbors. It also encouraged commenting on other games, which is exactly what we’re trying to do. It would be a nice way to complement the Feedback Friends, so if you have some skills & free time, you know what to do!

Comments

28. Jul 2016 · 23:23 UTC
Thanks so much for your hard work Wan! Your experimental @mention support in particular looks really exciting — it’s always been pretty inconvenient to reply to a comment in a way such that the author will actually see the reply. Perhaps this will help!
29. Jul 2016 · 05:28 UTC
Wow, great work! I really like this idea!

[ also love how the games appear on cartridges in the search, that’s a really nice touch. ]
Strike
29. Jul 2016 · 07:21 UTC
I really love it ! Awesome job done here. I realize now that I missed some replies from people which I just noticed thanks to you @nickname support. That’s a really important feature. I believe feedback is more important than ranking, so this is perfect to me :)
g_o
29. Jul 2016 · 11:17 UTC
I don’t really like it but well, better than nothing.

I mean of course it’s impressive that you made it in time, but as you know I’m not so impressed of the idea it’s based on.
29. Jul 2016 · 12:18 UTC
Good work Wan!
vfabien21
29. Jul 2016 · 13:30 UTC
I have tried it. That’s great.

But it only allows to efficiently see the top 20 or 50 entries in the category. Could we have page numbers at the bottom to browse a bit deeper ?
CyberStarLight
29. Jul 2016 · 15:05 UTC
The next LD just became better ^^

Nice work on the site, it seems to work very well! I hope to give it a test on the current MiniLD, I’m in it after all.

The only issue is with what vfabien21 said, it loads games really slowly and only shows a few per page.. maybe add another page with less images, stats, etc, that just orders and lists a lot of games with links? when the numbers go higher it’s going to be harder to navigate.
janiq
29. Jul 2016 · 16:16 UTC
Hi,

would it be possible to enable search also for the description?
29. Jul 2016 · 22:25 UTC
This is the best thing to ever happen to Ludum Dare. We have arrived.
30. Jul 2016 · 09:02 UTC
Well as this has been stickied, I’ll take it its the blessed way we do commenting for LD#36 and I’ll bow out with the map thing :)
30. Jul 2016 · 11:39 UTC
If location were used in FF, I feel strongly that it should be an opt-in feature, in order to protect user privacy. Not everyone may agree to their location being publically revealed. But without user authentication, what is to stop someone opting-in any user they wished to impersonate?
QualityCatGames
26. Aug 2016 · 06:20 UTC
i agree, there.
berkano
30. Jul 2016 · 11:22 UTC
Wow! Thanks so much for putting this together! It’s really boosted my motivation for LD36 :-)
Digitaldude555
30. Jul 2016 · 12:16 UTC
NO RATING? How will I judge the progress I have made over the years?
Naca
30. Jul 2016 · 15:14 UTC
Awesome work Wan!!
crazya02
31. Jul 2016 · 00:27 UTC
I honestly love this. The primary reason I participated in LD was the incentivized feedback, so this singlehandedly got me interested again.
kfischer_okarin
01. Aug 2016 · 18:06 UTC
I love it too!

A minor thing to be fixed maybe: If you embed your game but do not provide a link labeled (Web) then the game is not listed with the platform “Web” – which might discourage people from playing it even though they could…

Is there a possibility for you to detect that case?
02. Aug 2016 · 14:38 UTC
Okay, this looks absolutely sick! Like amazing! I totally can’t wait for LD 36 now! Thanks a lot!
03. Aug 2016 · 08:10 UTC
My game’s HTML5 but when I limit to HTML5 games, it doesn’t show up…am I doing something wrong? I have it hosted on itch.io, do I need to host it plane-Jane somewhere (not embedded in a page)?
Steven Miller
03. Aug 2016 · 10:25 UTC
Is there a way to check who is commenting in case they repeat? Because my game for miniLD #69 just got 6 comments from the same person and the priority dropped significantly. Also, I feel like replying on your own game page shouldn’t count (it might already not, I’m not too sure).
Wan
08. Aug 2016 · 10:19 UTC
You actually found a bug: normally we have a limit per commenter, thanks for noticing this.
03. Aug 2016 · 20:43 UTC
This is a great idea, I’m glad that there is some kinda system in place. 😀
04. Aug 2016 · 07:52 UTC
@Steven Miller I hope that gets implemented…as a first timer I went and posted three comments instead of waiting and consolidating, and I agree it’d probably be better to only count unique posters excluding oneself.
TerraCottaFrog
15. Aug 2016 · 22:09 UTC
Can you make this appear larger on the homepage to make sure that everyone sees it?
Alphish
22. Aug 2016 · 08:57 UTC
So, this time the balance depends entirely on the *comments* rather than *ratings*? Sweet~!
24. Aug 2016 · 06:41 UTC
Wow. Good initiative Wan! That’s will help a lot with this LD :)
Jelinib
31. Aug 2016 · 07:54 UTC
I tend to type long comments (commented 8 times, averaging 2.9p per comment right now), and it looks like I get more points for typing more(?)! Neat!