Good themes VS bad themes
When it comes to suggesting themes, I hope you guys consider these nuggets of, err, not necessarily wisdom, but... Something.
Bad theme considerations:
A game mechanic is not a good theme (e.g. "jumping")
A genre is not a good theme (e.g. "first person shooter")
A graphics style is not a good theme (e.g. "pixel art")
A super broad thing is not a good theme (e.g. "universe")
A limitation may be a good theme, but not always
Good theme considerations:
Good theme is open to interpretation (e.g. "up or down?")
Good theme does not limit game genres ("racing" is more limiting than "speed")
Good theme does not limit cultural genres ("anime" or "cyberpunk" would do so)
Good theme applies to all kinds of graphics styles, or even other media like tabletops
Good theme may reveal itself after the jam is done as we see how people interpreted it :)