Each Ludum Dare usually has different things that go badly and things that go well, but there is one dilemma that’s always the same for me.
Do I make something simple that I can polish and test properly? Or do I challenge myself to do the impossible?
Each option has its own pro’s and cons:
Something simple that I can polish and test properly
- I can make a finished product that works, looks good and sounds good, almost guaranteed.
- It’s more fun to read comments after LD has ended.
- Will likely end up higher in the rankings.
Challenge myself to do the impossible.
- More fun during ludum dare, more exciting.
- Less limiting
- It would be awesome if I actually managed to finish the game.
- Likely results in something incomplete/ buggy.
The first 2 times I entered I tried to make something ambitious, the last two times I tried to make something simpler. This time, I tried doing the impossible again.
I guess what it comes down to is who you think you are competing against. Am I competing against everyone who is also entering LD, then I should probably go for option one. Am I competing against myself, then I should go for option two.
Anyway, what I ended up with is more than I actually expected. My game is playable and I find it fun to experiment with it. But while there is a lot to try out, the game does not feel complete.
My game: Critter Criminal
In critter criminal you fight, catch, breed and butcher friendly critters for your own personal gain. In the ludum dare version fighting, catching, breeding and butchering all works, but once you’ve caught or bred the ultimate critter, there is not a whole lot to do with it.
If you’re into breeding type games, I think you can have fun with this entry but you’ll mostly have to set your own challenges.
You can play my entry here

